Editorial Pick
Herd Mentality
Write down the answer you think most people will write. Match the majority and score. Be the odd one out and you get stuck with the pink cow.
$17.49 on Amazon, checked Nov 22. In stock. All prices
Affiliate link · we may earn a commission · pick chosen on merit, not commission
Light weight
Herd Mentality
Why Herd Mentality.
Herd Mentality is a party game about thinking like everyone else. One player reads a question with no right answer, such as name a food you would eat at the cinema. Everyone writes an answer in secret. Then all answers are revealed, and whoever wrote the most common answer scores a point. If your answer is the only one of its kind, you take the pink cow, a squishy toy that stops you from winning until somebody else earns it.
That is the whole rule set, and it means the game can be explained in one breath and played by a table of four or a room of twenty. The fun comes from the arguments after each reveal, when someone has to defend writing nachos. It works across generations because the questions need no knowledge at all. People who like clever party games may find it slight next to Just One or Wavelength, which are both in this catalog. For a family gathering with a wide spread of ages, it is close to ideal.
No paid placement. No sponsorship. We chose it on merit. The Amazon link funds the lights - if you'd rather buy from a local game store, look it up on BoardGameGeek for other sellers.
Game night kit.
4-20 players, 20 min. Something to eat that will not grease the cards, something sweet for the table, and a gift idea for whoever keeps winning.
Pairings rotate with the catalog. Both sites are part of the Daily Picks Network; no affiliate link is involved in the pairing itself.
If you like Herd Mentality.
Other picks sharing at least two of the same contexts.

Word-association party game. Plays with grandparents, college kids, anyone in between.…

Cooperative party game. Give one-word clues. Sets up in 30 seconds.…

Bet on racing camels. Riotous, light, plays loud. The party-night pick.…

Surreal-art storytelling game. Cross-generational. Hits in mixed groups.…