PBG · 2026 Issue No. 2026.05 Editorial · Curated · Independent Updated weekly

Head-to-head comparison

Cartographers vs Sagrada

Both are puzzle games about filling a personal grid under changing rules. Sagrada is prettier on the table; Cartographers handles big groups and solo play better.

Cartographers Light weight Cartographers

$20.89, checked Nov 22.

1-99 30-45 min Light

Everyone draws the same shapes onto their own map of forests, farms and villages, then draws monsters on a neighbor's map. Works with any number.

Buy Cartographers · $20.89 →
Sagrada Light weight Sagrada

$59.99, checked Nov 22. Was $61.29 before Nov 19, down 2%. On the Black Friday drop list

1-4 30-45 min Light

Draft translucent dice to build a stained glass window. Beautiful, quiet, and sneakily hard.

Buy Sagrada · $59.99 →

Pick Cartographers if

You want everyone playing at once on their own map, with any number of people and a pencil each.

Pick Sagrada if

You want something to hold: translucent dice drafted in turn and slotted into a stained glass window.

Side by side.

FactCartographersSagrada
Players1-991-4
Playing time30-45 min30-45 min
WeightLightLight
Price today$20.89$59.99
  • Both play at two.
  • Both have a solo mode.
  • Biggest table: Cartographers seats 99, Sagrada stops at four.
  • Cheaper today: Cartographers by $39.10, prices checked Nov 22.

The tradeoff.

Cartographers

Cartographers is a flip-and-write game. Every player has a sheet with an empty grid and a pencil. Each turn a card is flipped showing a shape and a terrain type, and everyone draws that shape somewhere on their own map as forest, village, farmland or water. Four scoring cards, different every game, say what earns points: forests along the edge, for instance, or villages next to mountains. Two of the four are scored each season.

The moment people remember is the ambush. When a monster card comes up, you pass your map to a neighbor and they draw the monster shape wherever it hurts you most. Since everyone plays at the same time, the game takes the same half hour with two players or ten, and the solo mode is good. The listing says 1 to 99 players, and the real limit is the number of sheets and pencils. It is a little more thinky than most roll-and-write games, which is why it has lasted.

Best for: Solo, Family with Kids, For Introverts

Sagrada

Sagrada is a dice drafting puzzle where each player fills a small grid to build a stained glass window. Each round a pool of colored dice is rolled and players take turns picking one and placing it on their board. The rules are the whole game: a die cannot sit orthogonally next to another die of the same color or the same number, and each board has printed restrictions on certain squares that demand a specific color or value. Shared public objectives reward patterns like rows of different colors or sets of particular numbers, and a private objective rewards one color.

The result is a game that looks gentle and plays like a tightening knot. Early placements are free and easy; by the last two rounds you may have only one legal square left and the die you need is not in the pool. Tool cards, which let you bend the rules for a price, are the release valve, and knowing when to spend on them is most of the strategy. Because everyone drafts from the same pool, there is a light competitive edge as the die you wanted disappears, but nobody can attack you directly, which makes it a favorite with players who dislike conflict.

Best for: For Introverts, Two Players, Solo

These are editorial picks; publishers cannot pay to appear here. Amazon links fund the site, and if you'd rather buy local, find a store via BoardGameGeek.

Also worth considering.

Games that share contexts with both Cartographers and Sagrada.

The Weekend Slate

The games actually worth your weekend, in your inbox every Thursday.

One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.