PBG · 2026 Issue No. 2026.05 Editorial · Curated · Independent Updated weekly

Head-to-head comparison

Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition vs The Crew: Mission Deep Sea

Both reward people who already know Hearts or Spades. The Crew is easier to start with; Cat in the Box is the more unusual.

Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition Medium weight Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition

$20.96, checked Nov 22.

2-5 20-40 min Medium

A trick-taking game where the cards have no suit until you play them and say what they are. Claim the same card twice and you cause a paradox.

Buy Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition · $20.96 →
The Crew: Mission Deep Sea Light weight The Crew: Mission Deep Sea

$12.49, checked Nov 22.

2-5 20 min/mission Light

Cooperative trick-taking. 96 missions of escalating difficulty. Plays anywhere.

Buy The Crew: Mission Deep Sea · $12.49 →

Pick Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition if

You want a competitive trick-taker with a strange twist: cards have no colour until you declare one.

Pick The Crew: Mission Deep Sea if

You want a cooperative trick-taker with missions that get harder as the team improves.

Side by side.

FactCat in the Box: Deluxe EditionThe Crew: Mission Deep Sea
Players2-52-5
Playing time20-40 min20 min/mission
WeightMediumLight
Price today$20.96$12.49
  • Both play at two.
  • Both seat up to five.
  • Cheaper today: The Crew: Mission Deep Sea by $8.47, prices checked Nov 22.

The tradeoff.

Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition

Cat in the Box is a trick-taking game built on one clever idea. All the cards are black and show only a number. When you play a card, you declare which of the four colors it is and mark that color and number on a shared board. Once a red 5 has been claimed, nobody else may play a 5 as red. If you say you have no more of a color, you are locked out of it for the rest of the round.

As the board fills, your options shrink. Run out of legal plays and you cause a paradox, which ends the round and costs you points. Meanwhile you have bet on how many tricks you will win, and the tokens you place on the board score extra if they form a connected group. So it is part card game, part area puzzle. People who already enjoy Hearts, Spades or The Crew will get the most from it. It is a poor first trick-taker, since the twist only makes sense if you know what a normal one looks like.

Best for: Strategy Night, 3-4 Players, College Dorm

The Crew: Mission Deep Sea

The Crew is a cooperative trick-taking game where players work together to win specific tricks in a predetermined sequence rather than simply accumulating points. Each round, players play cards from their hand attempting to claim tricks that match mission objectives, sometimes you need the highest card, sometimes the lowest, sometimes you must win a specific number of tricks total. The core loop is immediate: play a card, resolve the trick, check if you've satisfied the mission requirement. It's elegant and familiar enough that experienced card players grasp it instantly, yet the cooperative constraint creates genuine tension since you can't simply announce your hand strength.

What distinguishes The Crew from lighter cooperative games is how tension builds across ninety-six escalating missions without requiring a rulebook expansion. Early missions teach the mechanics gently, but by mission forty you're managing intricate card combinations where winning a single trick might require silent communication through card play order. The table develops a focused, almost meditative energy, players lean in, count cards carefully, and celebrate narrow victories with genuine relief. It scratches an itch that solo puzzle games can't quite reach because failure comes from collective miscalculation, not luck, and success feels genuinely earned rather than fortunate.

Best for: Two Players, 3-4 Players, Cooperative

These are editorial picks; publishers cannot pay to appear here. Amazon links fund the site, and if you'd rather buy local, find a store via BoardGameGeek.

Also worth considering.

Games that share contexts with both Cat in the Box: Deluxe Edition and The Crew: Mission Deep Sea.

The Weekend Slate

The games actually worth your weekend, in your inbox every Thursday.

One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.