PBG · 2026 Issue No. 2026.05 Editorial · Curated · Independent Updated weekly

Head-to-head comparison

Outfoxed! vs Forbidden Island

Both are cooperative, so nobody loses alone. Outfoxed is the best first one; Forbidden Island is the natural second.

Outfoxed! Light weight Outfoxed!

$24, checked Nov 22.

2-4 15-20 min Light

A cooperative whodunit for ages five and up. Chicken detectives gather clues to work out which fox stole the pot pie before it escapes.

Buy Outfoxed! · $24 →
Forbidden Island Light weight Forbidden Island

$17.84, checked Nov 22. Was $20.99 before Nov 20, down 15%. On the Black Friday drop list

2-4 30 min Light

The cooperative gateway. Cheaper, simpler Pandemic. Plays with 8-year-olds.

Buy Forbidden Island · $17.84 →

Pick Outfoxed! if

The players are five to seven, and you want them solving a mystery together with dice and a clue decoder.

Pick Forbidden Island if

The players are eight and up and ready to plan a few turns ahead as a team.

Side by side.

FactOutfoxed!Forbidden Island
Players2-42-4
Playing time15-20 min30 min
WeightLightLight
Price today$24$17.84
  • Both play at two.
  • Both seat up to four.
  • Cheaper today: Forbidden Island by $6.16, prices checked Nov 22.

The tradeoff.

Outfoxed!

Outfoxed is a cooperative deduction game for young children. A fox has stolen Mrs. Plumpert's pot pie and the players, a team of chicken detectives, have to work out which of sixteen foxes did it. On your turn you choose to hunt for clues or reveal suspects, then roll three dice up to three times to earn that action. Clue tokens go into a plastic decoder that shows whether the thief is wearing a given item, such as a hat or a monocle. Suspects who do not match are ruled out.

Every failed roll moves the guilty fox closer to its escape hole, so the group shares a clock. The decoder gadget is the star: children love sliding the clue in and seeing the green dot. Because everyone wins or loses together, there are no tears over who came last, and five year olds can make real contributions. Adults will find it simple, as they should. It is one of the best first board games for a family, and a kind introduction to logic.

Best for: Family with Kids, Cooperative, Board Games for Beginners

Forbidden Island

Forbidden Island strips cooperative gaming down to its essentials. Players take on the roles of adventurers racing against time to collect four sacred treasures from a sinking island before making their escape. On your turn, you move around the island, shore up flooding tiles to prevent further submersion, or claim a treasure if you've gathered enough matching cards. The island deteriorates with each round as new tiles flood and previously flooded ones sink entirely. Victory requires both coordination and speed, but the mechanical loop remains straightforward enough that newcomers grasp it within minutes.

What distinguishes Forbidden Island is how efficiently it delivers cooperative tension without overwhelming the table. Unlike Pandemic, which can sprawl across rules and card interactions, this game creates urgency through sheer inevitability, the island will sink, and you'll need consensus on priorities without endless analysis paralysis. The shared puzzle feeling generates genuine moments of celebration when a risky plan works out. The thirty-minute runtime means even losing stings less, and the variable difficulty levels ensure it remains engaging across multiple plays rather than becoming a solved problem.

Best for: Two Players, Family with Kids, Cooperative

These are editorial picks; publishers cannot pay to appear here. Amazon links fund the site, and if you'd rather buy local, find a store via BoardGameGeek.

Also worth considering.

Games that share contexts with both Outfoxed! and Forbidden Island.

The Weekend Slate

The games actually worth your weekend, in your inbox every Thursday.

One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.