PBG · 2026 Issue No. 2026.05 Editorial · Curated · Independent Updated weekly

Head-to-head comparison

Secret Hitler vs The Resistance: Avalon

Both are hidden-role games for five to ten. Avalon is cheaper and has no theme to explain away; Secret Hitler gives more to argue about.

Secret Hitler Light weight Secret Hitler

$45, checked Nov 22.

5-10 45 min Light

A hidden-role game set in 1930s Germany. Liberals try to pass their policies and find the hidden fascists before it is too late. For 5 to 10 adults.

Buy Secret Hitler · $45 →
The Resistance: Avalon Light weight The Resistance: Avalon

$31.22, checked Nov 22. Was $29.58 before Nov 16, up 6%.

5-10 30 min Light

The definitive traitor game: missions, accusations, and a hidden Merlin who must help without being seen.

Buy The Resistance: Avalon · $31.22 →

Pick Secret Hitler if

You want a policy deck that forces honest players into bad plays, which gives everyone a reason to be suspected.

Pick The Resistance: Avalon if

You want the purer game of votes and missions, with Merlin knowing the traitors and trying not to be found.

Side by side.

FactSecret HitlerThe Resistance: Avalon
Players5-105-10
Playing time45 min30 min
WeightLightLight
Price today$45$31.22
  • Neither plays at two; both need at least five players.
  • Both seat up to ten.
  • Cheaper today: The Resistance: Avalon by $13.78, prices checked Nov 22.

The tradeoff.

Secret Hitler

Secret Hitler is a social deduction game for five to ten players, set in the German parliament of the 1930s. Each player is secretly a liberal or a fascist, and one fascist is Hitler. The fascists know each other. The liberals, who are the majority, know nothing. Each round the table elects a president and a chancellor. The president draws three policy tiles, discards one and passes two to the chancellor, who enacts one. Liberals win with five liberal policies. Fascists win with six of theirs, or by getting Hitler elected chancellor late in the game.

The policy deck holds more fascist tiles than liberal ones, so honest players are often forced to pass a bad law, and then have to convince the table that they had no choice. That built-in excuse for lying is why it produces better arguments than most games of its kind. As fascist policies pass, the president gains powers such as inspecting a loyalty card. The theme is dark by design and will not suit every group or any child. With the right table of adults it is among the best in its genre.

Best for: 5+ Players, College Dorm, Strategy Night

The Resistance: Avalon

The Resistance: Avalon hands five to ten players secret loyalty cards: most are loyal servants of Arthur, a hidden few are minions of Mordred. The game plays out over a series of missions. Each round a rotating leader proposes a team, the whole table debates and votes publicly on that team, and if the team is approved, its members secretly submit success or fail cards. Good needs three successful missions, evil needs three failures, and the entire information game runs through who proposed whom, who voted how, and which missions came back dirty. The twist that made Avalon the default version of The Resistance: Merlin secretly knows who the evil players are but must steer the table without exposing himself, because even if good wins the missions, the Assassin gets one shot to name Merlin and steal the game.

That Merlin mechanic is one of the best ideas in social deduction, full stop. It forces your most informed player to lie by omission all game, and it hands evil a comeback so no session feels decided early. There is no moderator and no player elimination, the two classic sins of Werewolf style games, and a round lands in about thirty minutes plus however long your table argues, which is always longer than you think.

Best for: 5+ Players, College Dorm, Holiday Gathering

These are editorial picks; publishers cannot pay to appear here. Amazon links fund the site, and if you'd rather buy local, find a store via BoardGameGeek.

Also worth considering.

Games that share contexts with both Secret Hitler and The Resistance: Avalon.

The Weekend Slate

The games actually worth your weekend, in your inbox every Thursday.

One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.